OpenLB
Open Library of Bioscience
Advanced Search
Philosophy, ethics, and humanities in medicine : PEHM
Dec 29, 2011;6 17.

Donation after cardiocirculatory death: a call for a moratorium pending full public disclosure and fully informed consent.

Ari R Joffe, Joe Carcillo, Natalie Anton, Allan deCaen, Yong Y Han, Michael J Bell, Frank A Maffei, John Sullivan, James Thomas, Gonzalo Garcia-Guerra
Author Information
  1. Ari R Joffe: Department of Pediatrics, University of Alberta, Stollery Children's Hospital, Edmonton Clinic Health Academy 11405-87 Avenue, Edmonton, Alberta, T6G 1C9, Canada. ari.joffe@albertahealthservices.ca
PMID: 22206616 DOI: 10.1186/1747-5341-6-17

Abstract

Many believe that the ethical problems of donation after cardiocirculatory death (DCD) have been "worked out" and that it is unclear why DCD should be resisted. In this paper we will argue that DCD donors may not yet be dead, and therefore that organ donation during DCD may violate the dead donor rule. We first present a description of the process of DCD and the standard ethical rationale for the practice. We then present our concerns with DCD, including the following: irreversibility of absent circulation has not occurred and the many attempts to claim it has have all failed; conflicts of interest at all steps in the DCD process, including the decision to withdraw life support before DCD, are simply unavoidable; potentially harmful premortem interventions to preserve organ utility are not justifiable, even with the help of the principle of double effect; claims that DCD conforms with the intent of the law and current accepted medical standards are misleading and inaccurate; and consensus statements by respected medical groups do not change these arguments due to their low quality including being plagued by conflict of interest. Moreover, some arguments in favor of DCD, while likely true, are "straw-man arguments," such as the great benefit of organ donation. The truth is that honesty and trustworthiness require that we face these problems instead of avoiding them. We believe that DCD is not ethically allowable because it abandons the dead donor rule, has unavoidable conflicts of interests, and implements premortem interventions which can hasten death. These important points have not been, but need to be fully disclosed to the public and incorporated into fully informed consent. These are tall orders, and require open public debate. Until this debate occurs, we call for a moratorium on the practice of DCD.

References

  1. Resuscitation. 1996 Jul;32(1):27-9 [PMID: 8809916]
  2. N Engl J Med. 2008 Aug 14;359(7):709-14 [PMID: 18703473]
  3. Chest. 2010 Jul;138(1):16-8; discussion 18-9 [PMID: 20605813]
  4. Crit Care Med. 2006 Apr;34(4):950-7 [PMID: 16484889]
  5. J Clin Ethics. 2006 Summer;17(2):133-6 [PMID: 16913147]
  6. Crit Care Med. 2004 May;32(5):1149-54 [PMID: 15190965]
  7. Resuscitation. 2006 Jul;70(1):44-51 [PMID: 16759784]
  8. Kennedy Inst Ethics J. 1993 Jun;3(2):231-9 [PMID: 10126535]
  9. Crit Care. 2005;9(6):538-42 [PMID: 16356234]
  10. Pediatrics. 2010 Aug;126(2):e489-91; author reply e492 [PMID: 20679309]
  11. Circulation. 1997 Nov 18;96(10):3308-13 [PMID: 9396421]
  12. JAMA. 1995 Mar 1;273(9):703-8 [PMID: 7853627]
  13. AMA Arch Intern Med. 1952 Jul;90(1):15-29 [PMID: 14932533]
  14. Arch Intern Med. 2005 Aug 8-22;165(15):1705-12 [PMID: 16087817]
  15. Transplant Proc. 1997 Feb-Mar;29(1-2):1378-80 [PMID: 9123347]
  16. Hastings Cent Rep. 2010 May-Jun;40(3):24-31 [PMID: 20549866]
  17. Am J Transplant. 2006 Feb;6(2):281-91 [PMID: 16426312]
  18. N Engl J Med. 2003 Sep 18;349(12):1123-32 [PMID: 13679526]
  19. N Engl J Med. 1997 Dec 11;337(24):1768-71 [PMID: 9392707]
  20. Ann Intern Med. 1981 Mar;94(3):389-94 [PMID: 7224389]
  21. Resuscitation. 1998 Oct-Nov;39(1-2):125-8 [PMID: 9918459]
  22. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2008 Oct;136(4):976-983.e3 [PMID: 18954639]
  23. Pediatr Crit Care Med. 2011 May;12(3):375-7; author reply 377-8 [PMID: 21637157]
  24. Crit Care Med. 2006 Dec;34(12):2952-8 [PMID: 17075366]
  25. Anaesth Intensive Care. 1991 Feb;19(1):118-21 [PMID: 2012271]
  26. J Exp Med. 1912 Sep 1;16(3):291-302 [PMID: 19867574]
  27. Lancet. 1982 May 1;1(8279):1019 [PMID: 6122830]
  28. J Law Med Ethics. 2008 Winter;36(4):760-5, 610 [PMID: 19094004]
  29. Resuscitation. 2010 Jun;81(6):671-5 [PMID: 20227813]
  30. Crit Care Med. 2010 Sep;38(9 Suppl):S502-9 [PMID: 20724884]
  31. Intensive Care Med. 2006 Feb;32(2):217-222 [PMID: 16432680]
  32. J Am Coll Surg. 2008 May;206(5):1028-37; discussion 1037 [PMID: 18471749]
  33. Pediatr Crit Care Med. 2010 Sep;11(5):641-3; author reply 643-5 [PMID: 20823743]
  34. BMC Med Ethics. 2006 Dec 22;7:E14 [PMID: 17187671]
  35. Pediatrics. 1994 Mar;93(3):532-6 [PMID: 8115226]
  36. Ann Thorac Surg. 2005 Jan;79(1):178-83; discussion 183-4 [PMID: 15620939]
  37. Chest. 2010 Jul;138(1):13-6 [PMID: 20605812]
  38. J Med Philos. 2010 Jun;35(3):242-55 [PMID: 20439357]
  39. Rev Esp Anestesiol Reanim. 2004 Aug-Sep;51(7):390-4 [PMID: 15495638]
  40. J Law Med Ethics. 1998 Summer;26(2):157-65 [PMID: 11657352]
  41. Circulation. 2007 Oct 9;116(15):1693-700 [PMID: 17893278]
  42. HEC Forum. 2009 Mar;21(1):71-106 [PMID: 19255729]
  43. Am Heart J. 1948 Jun;35(6):910-23 [PMID: 18863740]
  44. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2008 Mar;33(3):409-17 [PMID: 18206379]
  45. J Med Ethics. 2003 Jun;29(3):176-81 [PMID: 12796441]
  46. Resuscitation. 2004 Dec;63(3):311-20 [PMID: 15582767]
  47. Pediatr Emerg Care. 2005 Dec;21(12):807-15 [PMID: 16340755]
  48. Lancet. 2010 Sep 25;376(9746):1109-12 [PMID: 20870101]
  49. J Clin Ethics. 2010 Fall;21(3):224-8 [PMID: 21089992]
  50. Pediatr Emerg Care. 2011 Mar;27(3):208-9 [PMID: 21378522]
  51. Crit Care Med. 2008 Apr;36(4):1049-58 [PMID: 18379228]
  52. J Law Med Ethics. 2006 Spring;34(1):35-43, 3 [PMID: 16489982]
  53. PLoS One. 2011;6(9):e21236 [PMID: 21915252]
  54. Transplant Proc. 2002 Nov;34(7):2589-90 [PMID: 12431535]
  55. JAMA. 2003 Jul 9;290(2):252-5 [PMID: 12851281]
  56. J Med Philos. 2010 Jun;35(3):365-80 [PMID: 20439356]
  57. Intensive Care Med. 2009 Feb;35(2):240-7 [PMID: 18670759]
  58. Resuscitation. 2011 Jan;82(1):134 [PMID: 20970913]
  59. J Law Med Ethics. 2010 Fall;38(3):667-83 [PMID: 20880249]
  60. J Clin Ethics. 2010 Fall;21(3):243-63 [PMID: 21089996]
  61. Am J Bioeth. 2011 Aug;11(8):36-43 [PMID: 21806438]
  62. Crit Care Med. 2010 Aug;38(8):1761; author reply 1761-2 [PMID: 20647819]
  63. J Clin Ethics. 2009 Winter;20(4):316-26 [PMID: 20120851]
  64. CMAJ. 2006 Oct 10;175(8):905 [PMID: 17030941]
  65. Neurology. 2001 Mar 27;56(6):766-72 [PMID: 11274312]
  66. Ann Intern Med. 2006 Aug 1;145(3):224-5 [PMID: 16880464]
  67. Intensive Care Med. 2001 Nov;27(11):1744-9 [PMID: 11810117]
  68. Philos Ethics Humanit Med. 2007 Aug 24;2:18 [PMID: 17718918]
  69. J Law Med Ethics. 2008 Winter;36(4):766-71, 610 [PMID: 19094005]
  70. Hastings Cent Rep. 2010 May-Jun;40(3):3 [PMID: 20545099]
  71. Chest. 2008 Jun;133(6 Suppl):257S-298S [PMID: 18574268]
  72. Chest. 2008 Jun;133(6 Suppl):887S-968S [PMID: 18574281]
  73. Philos Ethics Humanit Med. 2007 Nov 25;2:28 [PMID: 18036254]
  74. Intensive Care Med. 2007 May;33(5):751-754 [PMID: 17342516]
  75. Crit Care Med. 2010 Mar;38(3):963-70 [PMID: 20124892]
  76. Issues Law Med. 2009 Fall;25(2):95-143 [PMID: 20101906]
  77. Intensive Care Med. 2009 Apr;35(4):623-30 [PMID: 18850088]
  78. Pediatr Crit Care Med. 2004 Sep;5(5):440-6 [PMID: 15329159]
  79. Pediatrics. 1999 Apr;103(4):e46 [PMID: 10103338]
  80. Crit Care Med. 2001 Sep;29(9):1826-31 [PMID: 11546995]
  81. J Med Ethics. 2005 Feb;31(2):64-8 [PMID: 15681666]
  82. Crit Care Med. 2006 Jun;34(6):1686-90 [PMID: 16625128]
  83. J Med Philos. 2010 Jun;35(3):313-29 [PMID: 20439354]
  84. Pediatrics. 2000 Aug;106(2 Pt 1):351-7 [PMID: 10920167]
  85. Intensive Care Med. 2009 Oct;35(10):1673-7 [PMID: 19590849]
  86. Transpl Int. 2011 Apr;24(4):368-72 [PMID: 21276090]
  87. Anesth Analg. 2001 Jul;93(1):241 [PMID: 11429378]
  88. J Palliat Med. 2009 Dec;12(12):1095-100 [PMID: 19803731]
  89. Resuscitation. 2010 Sep;81(9):1061-2 [PMID: 20650558]
  90. Crit Care Med. 2010 Jun;38(6):1498-9; author reply 1499 [PMID: 20502147]
  91. Geriatrics. 1970 Dec;25(12):91-100 [PMID: 5483789]
  92. Crit Care Med. 1985 Nov;13(11):930-1 [PMID: 4053643]
  93. Resuscitation. 2006 Sep;70(3):381-94 [PMID: 16828957]
  94. J Med Ethics. 1995 Oct;21(5):270-6 [PMID: 8558540]
  95. Pediatrics. 1998 Jun;101(6):1049-52 [PMID: 9606234]
  96. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2003 Jan 15;41(2):197-203 [PMID: 12535808]
  97. Hastings Cent Rep. 1998 Mar-Apr;28(2):14-23 [PMID: 9589289]
  98. CMAJ. 2006 Oct 10;175(8):S1 [PMID: 17124739]
  99. Camb Q Healthc Ethics. 2008 Winter;17(1):75-86 [PMID: 18462547]
  100. CMAJ. 2006 Mar 14;174(6):S1-13 [PMID: 16534069]
  101. Issues Law Med. 2002 Summer;18(1):3-20 [PMID: 12154561]
  102. Qual Saf Health Care. 2003 Feb;12(1):18-23 [PMID: 12571340]
  103. J Law Med Ethics. 2008 Winter;36(4):741-51, 610 [PMID: 19094002]
  104. Resuscitation. 2009 Mar;80(3):318-23 [PMID: 19185967]
  105. J Clin Ethics. 2006 Summer;17(2):122-32 [PMID: 16913146]
  106. J Appl Physiol (1985). 1998 Oct;85(4):1533-43 [PMID: 9760351]
  107. Am J Bioeth. 2011 Aug;11(8):W4-6 [PMID: 21806425]
  108. N Engl J Med. 2008 Aug 14;359(7):669-71 [PMID: 18703467]
  109. Kennedy Inst Ethics J. 1993 Jun;3(2):263-78 [PMID: 10126538]
  110. Ann Emerg Med. 1994 Aug;24(2):305-11 [PMID: 8037399]
  111. Paediatr Child Health. 2004 Feb;9(2):99-114 [PMID: 19654990]
  112. Resuscitation. 2010 Sep;81(9):1069-78 [PMID: 20678461]
  113. Am J Bioeth. 2011 Aug;11(8):45-7 [PMID: 21806440]
  114. Anesthesiology. 1998 Nov;89(5):1252-3 [PMID: 9822016]
  115. Bioethics. 2012 Jan;26(1):32-48 [PMID: 20459428]
  116. Can J Anaesth. 2009 Nov;56(11):851-63 [PMID: 19585180]
  117. Kennedy Inst Ethics J. 1993 Jun;3(2):167-78 [PMID: 10126529]
  118. Am J Bioeth. 2011 Aug;11(8):52-4 [PMID: 21806443]
  119. Crit Care Med. 2002 Feb;30(2):290-6 [PMID: 11889295]
  120. Am J Bioeth. 2011 Aug;11(8):58-9 [PMID: 21806446]
  121. Crit Care. 2006;10(5):166 [PMID: 17020597]
  122. Crit Care Med. 2010 May;38(5):1246-53 [PMID: 20228683]
  123. Neurology. 2010 Apr 6;74(14):1096-101 [PMID: 20368630]
  124. J Law Med Ethics. 2008 Winter;36(4):752-9, 610 [PMID: 19094003]
  125. Resuscitation. 2009 Jan;80(1):61-4 [PMID: 18992985]
  126. Kennedy Inst Ethics J. 1993 Jun;3(2):217-30 [PMID: 10126534]
  127. Anesthesiology. 1999 Aug;91(2):585-6 [PMID: 10443636]
  128. N Engl J Med. 2008 Aug 14;359(7):674-5 [PMID: 18703469]
  129. Haematologica. 2007 Feb;92(2):244-7 [PMID: 17296576]
  130. JAMA. 2009 May 13;301(18):1902-8 [PMID: 19436017]
  131. Transpl Int. 2003 Oct;16(10):736-41 [PMID: 12844215]
  132. Ann Intern Med. 2006 Aug 1;145(3):157-64 [PMID: 16880457]
  133. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2006 May;131(5):1114-21 [PMID: 16678598]
  134. Anesth Analg. 2001 Mar;92(3):690-2 [PMID: 11226103]
  135. Pediatrics. 2008 Nov;122(5):e967-74 [PMID: 18977964]
  136. Hastings Cent Rep. 2008 Nov-Dec;38(6):38-46 [PMID: 19192716]
  137. J Med Philos. 2010 Jun;35(3):299-312 [PMID: 20439355]
  138. Resuscitation. 2007 May;73(2):229-35 [PMID: 17258377]
  139. N Engl J Med. 2008 Aug 14;359(7):672-3 [PMID: 18703468]
  140. Pediatrics. 2010 Apr;125(4):822-8 [PMID: 20351011]

MeSH Term

Adult
Aged
Aged, 80 and over
Consensus
Death
Disclosure
Female
Humans
Informed Consent
Male
Middle Aged
Tissue and Organ Procurement
Journal Article
Article has an altmetric score of 7

Word Cloud

Created with Highcharts 10.0.0DCDdonationdeadorganincludingargumentsfullypublicbelieveethicalproblemscardiocirculatorydeathmaydonorrulepresentprocesspracticeconflictsinterestunavoidablepremorteminterventionsmedicalrequireinformedconsentdebatecallmoratoriumMany"workedout"unclearresistedpaperwillarguedonorsyetthereforeviolatefirstdescriptionstandardrationaleconcernsfollowing:irreversibilityabsentcirculationoccurredmanyattemptsclaimfailedstepsdecisionwithdrawlifesupportsimplypotentiallyharmfulpreserveutilityjustifiableevenhelpprincipledoubleeffectclaimsconformsintentlawcurrentacceptedstandardsmisleadinginaccurateconsensusstatementsrespectedgroupschangeduelowqualityplaguedconflictMoreoverfavorlikelytrue"straw-man"greatbenefittruthhonestytrustworthinessfaceinsteadavoidingethicallyallowableabandonsinterestsimplementscanhastenimportantpointsneeddisclosedincorporatedtallordersopenoccursDonationdeath:pendingfulldisclosure

Similar Articles

Cited By