Overdiagnosis in primary care: framing the problem and finding solutions.

Minal S Kale, Deborah Korenstein
Author Information
  1. Minal S Kale: Division of General Internal Medicine, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York, USA.
  2. Deborah Korenstein: Department of Medicine and Center for Health Policy and Outcomes, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY 10017, USA.

Abstract

Overdiagnosis, is defined as the diagnosis of a condition that, if unrecognized, would not cause symptoms or harm a patient during his or her lifetime, and it is increasingly acknowledged as a consequence of screening for cancer and other conditions. Because preventive care is a crucial component of primary care, which is delivered to the broad population, overdiagnosis in primary care is an important problem from a public health perspective and has far reaching implications. The scope of overdiagnosis as a result of services delivered in primary care is unclear, though overdiagnosis of indolent breast, prostate, thyroid, and lung cancers is well described and overdiagnosis of chronic kidney disease, depression, and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder is also recognized. However, overdiagnosis is a known consequence of all screening and can be assumed to occur in many more clinical contexts. Overdiagnosis can harm patients by leading to overtreatment (with associated potential toxicities), diagnosis related anxiety or depression, and labeling, or through financial burden. Many entrenched factors facilitate overdiagnosis, including the growing use of advanced diagnostic technology, financial incentives, a medical culture that encourages greater use of tests and treatments, limitations in the evidence that obscure the understanding of diagnostic utility, use of non-beneficial screening tests, and the broadening of disease definitions. Efforts to reduce overdiagnosis are hindered by physicians' and patients' lack of awareness of the problem and by confusion about terminology, with overdiagnosis often conflated with related concepts. Clarity of terminology would facilitate physicians' understanding of the problem and the growth in evidence regarding its prevalence and downstream consequences in primary care. It is hoped that international coordination regarding diagnostic standards for disease definitions will also help minimize overdiagnosis in the future.

References

  1. JAMA. 2017 Mar 21;317(11):1159-1166 [PMID: 28324090]
  2. BMJ. 2008 Jan 19;336(7636):126-9 [PMID: 18202066]
  3. JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2017 Jul 1;143(7):663-669 [PMID: 28278335]
  4. PLoS One. 2018 Feb 5;13(2):e0192097 [PMID: 29401514]
  5. N Engl J Med. 2016 Aug 18;375(7):614-7 [PMID: 27532827]
  6. JAMA Intern Med. 2017 Jul 1;177(7):1020-1025 [PMID: 28505266]
  7. Lancet Oncol. 2016 Oct;17(10):e442-e451 [PMID: 27733270]
  8. BMJ. 2011 Sep 07;343:d4684 [PMID: 21903693]
  9. J Med Ethics. 2016 Nov;42(11):705-714 [PMID: 27402883]
  10. JAMA. 2007 Sep 12;298(10):1209-12 [PMID: 17848656]
  11. JAMA. 2017 Jun 27;317(24):2479-2480 [PMID: 28520871]
  12. J Am Coll Radiol. 2010 Oct;7(10):754-73 [PMID: 20889105]
  13. Ann Intern Med. 2017 Jan 17;166(2):128-132 [PMID: 27893062]
  14. BMJ. 2015 Mar 04;350:h869 [PMID: 25740625]
  15. Diabetologia. 2013 Jul;56(7):1489-93 [PMID: 23584433]
  16. J Natl Cancer Inst. 2010 May 5;102(9):605-13 [PMID: 20413742]
  17. N Engl J Med. 1967 May 4;276(18):1008-13 [PMID: 6022469]
  18. Psychol Sci Public Interest. 2007 Nov;8(2):53-96 [PMID: 26161749]
  19. BMJ. 2015 Aug 25;351:h4534 [PMID: 26306661]
  20. BMJ. 1996 Jan 13;312(7023):71-2 [PMID: 8555924]
  21. BMJ. 2015 Jan 07;350:g7773 [PMID: 25569206]
  22. J Natl Cancer Inst. 2000 Aug 16;92(16):1280-2 [PMID: 10944539]
  23. Diabetes Care. 1997 May;20(5):785-91 [PMID: 9135943]
  24. BMJ. 2002 Apr 13;324(7342):886-91 [PMID: 11950740]
  25. J Hypertens. 2018 Apr;36(4):933-938 [PMID: 29227377]
  26. N Engl J Med. 2008 Oct 2;359(14):1424-5 [PMID: 18832242]
  27. BMJ. 2015 Mar 03;350:h825 [PMID: 25736421]
  28. BMC Cancer. 2015 Nov 06;15:858 [PMID: 26546276]
  29. Health Expect. 2015 Jun;18(3):355-65 [PMID: 23252477]
  30. Arch Intern Med. 2012 Jun 25;172(12):955-8 [PMID: 22473672]
  31. CMAJ. 2012 Oct 16;184(15):1687-96 [PMID: 23073674]
  32. JAMA. 2017 Jun 27;317(24):2515-2523 [PMID: 28655017]
  33. PLoS One. 2015 May 20;10(5):e0125165 [PMID: 25992887]
  34. Tidsskr Nor Laegeforen. 2016 Dec 06;136(22):1903-1905 [PMID: 27929558]
  35. PLoS Med. 2006 Apr;3(4):e198 [PMID: 16597181]
  36. Med J Aust. 2017 May 15;206(9):407-411 [PMID: 28490292]
  37. Am Fam Physician. 2015 Mar 1;91(5):289-91 [PMID: 25822384]
  38. J Korean Med Sci. 2012 Dec;27(12):1491-8 [PMID: 23255848]
  39. Soc Sci Med. 2011 Sep;73(6):825-32 [PMID: 21835526]
  40. BMJ. 2016 Feb 05;352:i348 [PMID: 26850726]
  41. Eur J Gen Pract. 2017 Dec;23(1):78-82 [PMID: 28299948]
  42. Arch Intern Med. 2012 Nov 26;172(21):1628-33 [PMID: 23089902]
  43. Lancet. 2015 Apr 25;385(9978):1642-52 [PMID: 25701273]
  44. Ann Intern Med. 2013 Jun 4;158(11):831-8 [PMID: 23732716]
  45. JAMA. 1979 Feb 2;241(5):489-94 [PMID: 759664]
  46. BMJ. 2014 Jul 15;349:g4485 [PMID: 25028385]
  47. J Natl Cancer Inst. 2006 Oct 4;98(19):1416-9 [PMID: 17018788]
  48. CMAJ. 2013 Jul 9;185(10):E492-8 [PMID: 23754101]
  49. BMJ. 2015 Mar 03;350:h980 [PMID: 25736617]
  50. Ann Intern Med. 2016 Feb 16;164(4):256-67 [PMID: 26756737]
  51. Br J Gen Pract. 2016 Aug;66(649):e587-92 [PMID: 27266859]
  52. BMJ. 2015 Mar 03;350:h867 [PMID: 25736426]
  53. N Engl J Med. 2017 Jun 8;376(23):2208-2209 [PMID: 28591536]
  54. Health Aff (Millwood). 2010 Dec;29(12):2244-51 [PMID: 21134926]
  55. Prev Med. 2011 Sep;53(3):134-40 [PMID: 21718717]
  56. Am Fam Physician. 2014 Nov 1;90(9):625-31 [PMID: 25368922]
  57. Circ Cardiovasc Qual Outcomes. 2016 Sep;9(5):504-12 [PMID: 27553599]
  58. Age Ageing. 2015 Jan;44(1):46-53 [PMID: 25103030]
  59. Eur Urol. 2000 Jul;38(1):74-8 [PMID: 10859445]
  60. Arch Intern Med. 2010 Mar 8;170(5):440-50 [PMID: 20212180]
  61. Ann Intern Med. 2015 Jun 2;162(11):765-76 [PMID: 25867111]
  62. JAMA Intern Med. 2017 Mar 1;177(3):352-357 [PMID: 28114439]
  63. Aust Fam Physician. 2013 Dec;42(12):856-9 [PMID: 24324985]
  64. Virtual Mentor. 2014 Feb 01;16(2):131-4 [PMID: 24553334]
  65. West J Med. 2000 Feb;172(2):124-8 [PMID: 10693376]
  66. JAMA Intern Med. 2014 Jul;174(7):1067-76 [PMID: 24819824]
  67. Diagnosis (Berl). 2015 Jun;2(2):97-103 [PMID: 26955512]
  68. Breast Cancer Res. 2016 May 10;18(1):47 [PMID: 27160733]
  69. Lancet. 2008 Jul 19;372(9634):246-55 [PMID: 18640461]
  70. BMJ. 2002 Apr 13;324(7342):905-7 [PMID: 11950744]
  71. JAMA. 2004 Jan 7;291(1):71-8 [PMID: 14709578]
  72. Clin Chem Lab Med. 2016 Mar;54(3):389-96 [PMID: 26444364]
  73. Health Aff (Millwood). 2015 Apr;34(4):576-83 [PMID: 25847639]
  74. Am J Psychiatry. 2012 May;169(5):465-75 [PMID: 22764360]
  75. Eur J Gen Pract. 2017 Dec;23(1):215-216 [PMID: 28914565]
  76. JAMA. 1998 Sep 16;280(11):1000-5 [PMID: 9749483]
  77. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2012 Apr;97(4):1067-72 [PMID: 22238408]
  78. Eur J Cancer. 2017 Jan;71:95-108 [PMID: 27987454]
  79. BMJ. 2013 Jul 02;347:f3368 [PMID: 23820021]
  80. J Med Screen. 2012;19 Suppl 1:42-56 [PMID: 22972810]
  81. Ann Intern Med. 2016 Feb 16;164(4):279-96 [PMID: 26757170]
  82. Ann Intern Med. 2012 Jun 19;156(12):880-91, W312 [PMID: 22711081]
  83. J Gen Intern Med. 2015 Feb;30(2):242-8 [PMID: 25150033]
  84. BMJ Open. 2017 Dec 27;7(12):e018448 [PMID: 29284720]
  85. Nephron Clin Pract. 2011;119 Suppl 1:c2-4 [PMID: 21832853]
  86. BMJ Open. 2017 Dec 12;7(12):e017565 [PMID: 29237653]
  87. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2012 Aug 15;37(18):1617-27 [PMID: 22415000]
  88. BMJ. 2005 Apr 2;330(7494):781-3 [PMID: 15802723]
  89. Thyroid. 2016 Jan;26(1):1-133 [PMID: 26462967]
  90. BMJ Open. 2015 Jul 28;5(7):e008155 [PMID: 26220870]
  91. Eur Urol. 2013 Sep;64(3):347-54 [PMID: 23856038]
  92. J Nerv Ment Dis. 2012 Jun;200(6):474-9 [PMID: 22652609]
  93. Acad Emerg Med. 2013 Nov;20(11):1194-206 [PMID: 24238322]
  94. Diabetologia. 2017 Nov;60(11):2192-2199 [PMID: 28831539]
  95. Maturitas. 2014 Dec;79(4):481-6 [PMID: 25277123]
  96. Pediatrics. 2014 Nov;134(5):1013-23 [PMID: 25287462]
  97. JAMA. 2012 Apr 11;307(14):1513-6 [PMID: 22419800]
  98. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2018 Jan;218(1):68-74 [PMID: 28571724]
  99. JAMA Intern Med. 2014 Feb 1;174(2):259-68 [PMID: 24322626]
  100. BMJ. 2013 Jul 29;347:f4298 [PMID: 23900313]
  101. CMAJ Open. 2017 Aug 11;5(3):E612-E616 [PMID: 28807924]
  102. JAMA Intern Med. 2013 Dec 9-23;173(22):2086-7 [PMID: 24145597]
  103. Ann Oncol. 2015 Sep;26 Suppl 5:v69-77 [PMID: 26205393]
  104. Med Care. 2017 Oct;55(10):879-885 [PMID: 28857962]
  105. N Engl J Med. 2013 Jul 18;369(3):245-254 [PMID: 23863051]
  106. Fam Pract. 2015 Apr;32(2):127-8 [PMID: 25805809]
  107. Lancet. 2017 Nov 11;390(10108):2128-2130 [PMID: 29143744]
  108. Lancet. 2012 Nov 17;380(9855):1778-86 [PMID: 23117178]
  109. Int J Cancer. 2017 Jun 1;140(11):2436-2443 [PMID: 28073150]

Grants

  1. P30 CA008748/NCI NIH HHS
  2. K07 CA187071/NCI NIH HHS

MeSH Term

Humans
Mass Screening
Medical Overuse
Primary Health Care

Word Cloud

Created with Highcharts 10.0.0overdiagnosiscareprimaryproblemOverdiagnosisscreeningdiseaseusediagnosticdiagnosisharmconsequencedelivereddepressionalsocanrelatedfinancialfacilitatetestsevidenceunderstandingdefinitionsphysicians'terminologyregardingdefinedconditionunrecognizedcausesymptomspatientlifetimeincreasinglyacknowledgedcancerconditionspreventivecrucialcomponentbroadpopulationimportantpublichealthperspectivefarreachingimplicationsscoperesultservicesunclearthoughindolentbreastprostatethyroidlungcancerswelldescribedchronickidneyattention-deficit/hyperactivitydisorderrecognizedHoweverknownassumedoccurmanyclinicalcontextspatientsleadingovertreatmentassociatedpotentialtoxicitiesanxietylabelingburdenManyentrenchedfactorsincludinggrowingadvancedtechnologyincentivesmedicalcultureencouragesgreatertreatmentslimitationsobscureutilitynon-beneficialbroadeningEffortsreducehinderedpatients'lackawarenessconfusionoftenconflatedconceptsClaritygrowthprevalencedownstreamconsequenceshopedinternationalcoordinationstandardswillhelpminimizefuturecare:framingfindingsolutions

Similar Articles

Cited By