Assessing Urban Health Inequities through a Multidimensional and Participatory Framework: Evidence from the EURO-HEALTHY Project.

Ângela Freitas, Teresa C Rodrigues, Paula Santana
Author Information
  1. Ângela Freitas: CEGOT-UC, Centre of Studies in Geography and Spatial Planning, University of Coimbra, Coimbra, Portugal. angela.freitas@uc.pt. ORCID
  2. Teresa C Rodrigues: CEG-IST, Centre for Management Studies of Instituto Superior Técnico, Universidade de Lisboa, Lisbon, Portugal.
  3. Paula Santana: CEGOT-UC, Centre of Studies in Geography and Spatial Planning, Department of Geography and Tourism, University of Coimbra, Coimbra, Portugal.

Abstract

Urban health inequities often reflect and follow the geographic patterns of inequality in the social, economic and environmental conditions within a city-the so-called determinants of health. Evidence of patterns within these conditions can support decision-making by identifying where action is urgent and which policies and interventions are needed to mitigate negative impacts and enhance positive impacts. Within the scope of the EU-funded project EURO-HEALTHY (Shaping EUROpean policies to promote HEALTH equitY), the City of Lisbon was selected as a case study to apply a multidimensional and participatory assessment approach of urban health whose purpose was to inform the evaluation of policies and interventions with potential to address local health gaps. In this paper, we present the set of indicators identified as drivers of urban health inequities within the City of Lisbon, exploring the added value of using a spatial indicator framework together with a participation process to orient a place-based assessment and to inform policies aimed at reducing health inequities. Two workshops with a panel of local stakeholders from health and social care services, municipal departments (e.g. urban planning, environment, social rights and education) and non-governmental and community-based organizations were organized. The aim was to engage local stakeholders to identify locally critical situations and select indicators of health determinants from a spatial equity perspective. To support the analysis, a matrix of 46 indicators of health determinants, with data disaggregated at the city neighbourhood scale, was constructed and was complemented with maps. The panel identified critical situations for urban health equity in 28 indicators across eight intervention axes: economic conditions, social protection and security; education; demographic change; lifestyles and behaviours; physical environment; built environment; road safety and healthcare resources and performance. The geographical distribution of identified critical situations showed that all 24 city neighbourhoods presented one or more problems. A group of neighbourhoods systematically perform worse in most indicators from different intervention axes, requiring not only priority action but mainly a multi- and intersectoral policy response. The indicator matrices and maps have provided a snapshot of urban inequities across different intervention axes, making a compelling argument for boosting intersectoral work across municipal departments and local stakeholders in the City of Lisbon. This study, by integrating local evidence in combination with social elements, pinpoints the importance of a place-based approach for assessing urban health equity.

Keywords

References

  1. PLoS Med. 2012;9(8):e1001285 [PMID: 22904689]
  2. Soc Sci Med. 2005 Mar;60(5):1017-33 [PMID: 15589671]
  3. Health Res Policy Syst. 2020 Feb 13;18(1):18 [PMID: 32054540]
  4. Int J Equity Health. 2015 Nov 20;14:138 [PMID: 26590020]
  5. J Urban Health. 2018 Oct;95(5):613-646 [PMID: 29663118]
  6. Soc Sci Med. 2015 Nov;145:237-42 [PMID: 26456133]
  7. Health Promot Int. 2015 Sep;30 Suppl 2:ii126-43 [PMID: 26420808]
  8. Am J Public Health. 2016 Apr;106(4):637-9 [PMID: 26959267]
  9. Public Health Rep. 2014 Jan-Feb;129 Suppl 2:5-8 [PMID: 24385658]
  10. Value Health. 2017 Feb;20(2):256-260 [PMID: 28237205]
  11. J Urban Health. 2007 May;84(3 Suppl):i16-26 [PMID: 17356903]
  12. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2017 Jan 26;14(2): [PMID: 28134756]
  13. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2016 Jul 13;13(7): [PMID: 27420090]
  14. Int J Equity Health. 2019 Jun 25;18(1):100 [PMID: 31238946]
  15. BMC Public Health. 2018 Apr 27;18(1):557 [PMID: 29703176]
  16. J Urban Health. 2016 Jun;93(3):526-37 [PMID: 27184570]
  17. Scand J Public Health. 2011 Mar;39(6 Suppl):11-8 [PMID: 20813799]
  18. Int J Health Policy Manag. 2014 Sep 02;3(4):161-3 [PMID: 25279377]
  19. Health Econ. 2002 Dec;11(8):659-66 [PMID: 12457367]
  20. Int J Equity Health. 2020 Jun 26;19(1):104 [PMID: 32586388]
  21. J Urban Health. 2020 Jun;97(3):418-435 [PMID: 31482385]
  22. J Urban Health. 2018 Oct;95(5):647-661 [PMID: 29039133]
  23. J Urban Health. 2010 Sep;87(5):727-32 [PMID: 20811780]
  24. J Urban Health. 2019 Aug;96(4):514-536 [PMID: 31214975]
  25. J Urban Health. 2018 Oct;95(5):610-612 [PMID: 29679220]
  26. Soc Sci Med. 2007 Nov;65(9):1825-38 [PMID: 17706331]
  27. J Urban Health. 2014 Aug;91(4):623-36 [PMID: 25047156]
  28. BMC Public Health. 2015 May 16;15:494 [PMID: 25981640]
  29. J Urban Health. 2013 Oct;90 Suppl 1:4-13 [PMID: 23990344]
  30. Annu Rev Public Health. 2016;37:113-33 [PMID: 26789382]
  31. J Epidemiol Community Health. 2003 Apr;57(4):254-8 [PMID: 12646539]
  32. J Epidemiol Community Health. 2020 Nov;74(11):964-968 [PMID: 32535550]
  33. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2019 Mar 07;16(5): [PMID: 30866549]

MeSH Term

Cities
Europe
Health Status Disparities
Humans
Urban Health

Word Cloud

Created with Highcharts 10.0.0healthurbansociallocalindicatorsinequitiespoliciesLisbonequityUrbanconditionswithindeterminantsCityassessmentapproachidentifiedstakeholdersenvironmentcriticalsituationsacrossinterventionpatternseconomicEvidencesupportactioninterventionsimpactsEURO-HEALTHYstudyinformspatialindicatorplace-basedpanelmunicipaldepartmentseducationcitymapsneighbourhoodsdifferentaxesintersectoralMultidimensionalParticipatoryoftenreflectfollowgeographicinequalityenvironmentalcity-theso-calledcandecision-makingidentifyingurgentneededmitigatenegativeenhancepositiveWithinscopeEU-fundedprojectShapingEUROpeanpromoteHEALTHequitYselectedcaseapplymultidimensionalparticipatorywhosepurposeevaluationpotentialaddressgapspaperpresentsetdriversexploringaddedvalueusingframeworktogetherparticipationprocessorientaimedreducingTwoworkshopscareservicesegplanningrightsnon-governmentalcommunity-basedorganizationsorganizedaimengageidentifylocallyselectperspectiveanalysismatrix46datadisaggregatedneighbourhoodscaleconstructedcomplemented28eightaxes:protectionsecuritydemographicchangelifestylesbehavioursphysicalbuiltroadsafetyhealthcareresourcesperformancegeographicaldistributionshowed24presentedoneproblemsgroupsystematicallyperformworserequiringprioritymainlymulti-policyresponsematricesprovidedsnapshotmakingcompellingargumentboostingworkintegratingevidencecombinationelementspinpointsimportanceassessingAssessingHealthInequitiesFramework:ProjectDeterminantsIndicatorsLocallevelStakeholderengagement

Similar Articles

Cited By