Intervention hesitancy among healthcare personnel: conceptualizing beyond vaccine hesitancy.

Rachel Gur-Arie, Nadav Davidovitch, Anat Rosenthal
Author Information
  1. Rachel Gur-Arie: Berman Institute of Bioethics, Johns Hopkins University, Deering Hall, 1809 Ashland Avenue, 21205, Baltimore, Maryland, USA. rgurari1@jhu.edu. ORCID
  2. Nadav Davidovitch: Department of Health Policy and Management, School of Public Health, Faculty of Health Sciences, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Be'er Sheva, Israel.
  3. Anat Rosenthal: Department of Health Policy and Management, School of Public Health, Faculty of Health Sciences, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Be'er Sheva, Israel.

Abstract

We propose an emerging conceptualization of "intervention hesitancy" to address a broad spectrum of hesitancy to disease prevention interventions among healthcare personnel (HCP) beyond vaccine hesitancy. To demonstrate this concept and its analytical benefits, we used a qualitative case-study methodology, identifying a "spectrum" of disease prevention interventions based on (1) the intervention's effectiveness, (2) how the intervention is regulated among HCP in the Israeli healthcare system, and (3) uptake among HCP in the Israeli healthcare system. Our cases ultimately contribute to a more nuanced conceptualization of hesitancy that HCP express towards disease prevention interventions. Our case interventions included the seasonal influenza vaccine, the Mantoux test, and the hepatitis B (HBV) vaccine. Influenza and HBV are vaccine-preventable diseases, though their respective vaccines vary significantly in effectiveness and uptake among HCP. The Mantoux test is a tuberculin skin test which provides a prevention benchmark for tuberculosis (TB), a non-vaccine preventable disease. We conducted semi-structured interviews with relevant stakeholders and analyzed them within Israeli and international policy context between 2016 and 2019, a period just prior to the COVID-19 pandemic. We propose the conceptualization of "intervention hesitancy"-beyond "vaccine hesitancy"-as "hesitancy towards a wide range of public health interventions, including but not limited to vaccines". Results suggested that intervention hesitancy among HCP is rooted in weak trust in their employer, poor employment conditions, as well as mixed institutional guidelines and culture. Conceptualizing intervention hesitancy expands the ability of healthcare systems to understand the root of hesitancy and foster a supportive institutional culture and trust, cognizant of diverse disease prevention interventions beyond vaccination.

Keywords

References

  1. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol. 2002 Jun;23(6):325-7 [PMID: 12083236]
  2. Eur Respir J. 2006 Dec;28(6):1216-21 [PMID: 16807264]
  3. JAMA Intern Med. 2013 Feb 11;173(3):242-4 [PMID: 23247811]
  4. AIDS. 2000 Jun;14 Suppl 1:S11-21 [PMID: 10981470]
  5. Vaccine. 2008 Jun 2;26(23):2942-8 [PMID: 18448210]
  6. J Health Commun. 2015;20(11):1287-93 [PMID: 26132725]
  7. Ann Gastroenterol. 2015 Apr-Jun;28(2):276-280 [PMID: 25830669]
  8. J Infect Dis. 2006 Nov 1;194 Suppl 2:S111-8 [PMID: 17163383]
  9. Cult Med Psychiatry. 2016 Jun;40(2):242-62 [PMID: 26374749]
  10. Vaccine. 2018 Apr 5;36(15):1996-2004 [PMID: 29519593]
  11. Lancet. 2009 Nov 14;374(9702):1653 [PMID: 19914498]
  12. MMWR Recomm Rep. 2006 Feb 24;55(RR-2):1-16 [PMID: 16498385]
  13. EBioMedicine. 2015 Jul 02;2(8):792-3 [PMID: 26425679]
  14. Hum Resour Health. 2017 Feb 3;15(1):11 [PMID: 28159017]
  15. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol. 2006 May;27(5):484-92 [PMID: 16671030]
  16. Health Syst Transit. 2015;17(6):1-212 [PMID: 27050102]
  17. Qual Saf Health Care. 2004 Apr;13(2):92-7 [PMID: 15069214]
  18. Vaccine. 2016 Sep 22;34(41):5013-5020 [PMID: 27576074]
  19. Biomed Res Int. 2017;2017:7538037 [PMID: 28337457]
  20. Health Policy. 2016 Aug;120(8):920-7 [PMID: 27496154]
  21. Isr J Health Policy Res. 2016 Jun 07;5:21 [PMID: 27280014]
  22. EBioMedicine. 2015 Jun 23;2(8):891-7 [PMID: 26425696]
  23. J Hepatol. 2003;39 Suppl 1:S89-92 [PMID: 14708684]
  24. Lancet. 2022 Apr 30;399(10336):e39-e40 [PMID: 32305074]
  25. J Infect Public Health. 2013 Aug;6(4):246-51 [PMID: 23806698]
  26. Am J Prev Med. 1998 Jul;15(1):1-8 [PMID: 9651632]
  27. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2018 Feb 16;67(6):180-185 [PMID: 29447141]
  28. Vaccine. 2009 Jun 24;27(31):4240-3 [PMID: 19481314]
  29. Isr J Health Policy Res. 2019 Jul 15;8(1):63 [PMID: 31307532]
  30. Vaccine. 2015 Aug 14;33(34):4161-4 [PMID: 25896383]
  31. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2019 May 17;68(19):439-443 [PMID: 31099768]
  32. Vaccine. 2011 Mar 24;29(15):2727-9 [PMID: 21316498]
  33. Vaccine. 2014 Apr 17;32(19):2150-9 [PMID: 24598724]
  34. J Adv Nurs. 2005 Dec;52(5):546-53 [PMID: 16268861]
  35. Health Serv Res. 2011 Aug;46(4):1281-99 [PMID: 21352224]
  36. Isr J Health Policy Res. 2016 Oct 26;5:52 [PMID: 27800154]
  37. Am J Infect Control. 2014 Aug;42(8):829-33 [PMID: 24939516]
  38. Emerg Infect Dis. 2004 Nov;10(11):1984-9 [PMID: 15550212]
  39. PLoS One. 2011;6(10):e26239 [PMID: 22028840]
  40. Vaccine. 2011 Jun 6;29(25):4293-7 [PMID: 21419165]
  41. AAOHN J. 1995 Mar;43(3):131-7 [PMID: 7702679]
  42. Hum Resour Health. 2015 Mar 31;13:16 [PMID: 25889952]
  43. Indian Dermatol Online J. 2012 Jan;3(1):2-6 [PMID: 23130251]
  44. Isr J Health Policy Res. 2021 Aug 2;10(1):43 [PMID: 34340714]
  45. Isr Med Assoc J. 2010 Jun;12(6):338-41 [PMID: 20928986]
  46. Isr J Health Policy Res. 2015 Apr 15;4:18 [PMID: 25878770]
  47. Clin Microbiol Infect. 2017 May;23(5):279-280 [PMID: 27851999]
  48. Ethn Health. 2018 May;23(4):442-459 [PMID: 28100067]
  49. Health Policy. 2012 May;105(2-3):203-13 [PMID: 22473245]
  50. BMC Health Serv Res. 2019 Jan 21;19(1):53 [PMID: 30665401]
  51. BMJ. 1997 Feb 1;314(7077):329-33 [PMID: 9040320]

Grants

  1. /Wellcome Trust
  2. Wellcome Trust/Wellcome Trust

MeSH Term

Humans
Pandemics
COVID-19
Health Personnel
Influenza Vaccines
Delivery of Health Care

Chemicals

Influenza Vaccines

Word Cloud

Created with Highcharts 10.0.0hesitancyinterventionsamongHCPdiseasepreventionhealthcarevaccineconceptualizationbeyondinterventionIsraelitestpropose"interventionpersonneleffectivenesssystemuptaketowardsMantouxHBVhealthtrustinstitutionalcultureInterventionemerginghesitancy"addressbroadspectrumdemonstrateconceptanalyticalbenefitsusedqualitativecase-studymethodologyidentifying"spectrum"based1intervention's2regulated3casesultimatelycontributenuancedexpresscaseincludedseasonalinfluenzahepatitisBInfluenzavaccine-preventablediseasesthoughrespectivevaccinesvarysignificantlytuberculinskinprovidesbenchmarktuberculosisTBnon-vaccinepreventableconductedsemi-structuredinterviewsrelevantstakeholdersanalyzedwithininternationalpolicycontext20162019periodjustpriorCOVID-19pandemichesitancy"-beyond"vaccinehesitancy"-as"hesitancywiderangepublicincludinglimitedvaccines"ResultssuggestedrootedweakemployerpooremploymentconditionswellmixedguidelinesConceptualizingexpandsabilitysystemsunderstandrootfostersupportivecognizantdiversevaccinationpersonnel:conceptualizingHealthcareInfectioncontrolNonpharmaceuticalOccupationalPolicyTrustVaccines

Similar Articles

Cited By