Discovery of interconnected causal drivers of COVID-19 vaccination intentions in the US using a causal Bayesian network.

Henry Fung, Sema K Sgaier, Vincent S Huang
Author Information
  1. Henry Fung: Surgo Health, Washington, DC, USA.
  2. Sema K Sgaier: Surgo Health, Washington, DC, USA. semasgaier@surgohealth.com.
  3. Vincent S Huang: Surgo Health, Washington, DC, USA.

Abstract

Holistic interventions to overcome COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy require a system-level understanding of the interconnected causes and mechanisms that give rise to it. However, conventional correlative analyses do not easily provide such nuanced insights. We used an unsupervised, hypothesis-free causal discovery algorithm to learn the interconnected causal pathways to vaccine intention as a causal Bayesian network (BN), using data from a COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy survey in the US in early 2021. We identified social responsibility, vaccine safety and anticipated regret as prime candidates for interventions and revealed a complex network of variables that mediate their influences. Social responsibility's causal effect greatly exceeded that of other variables. The BN revealed that the causal impact of political affiliations was weak compared with more direct causal factors. This approach provides clearer targets for intervention than regression, suggesting it can be an effective way to explore multiple causal pathways of complex behavioural problems to inform interventions.

References

  1. Front Artif Intell. 2021 Apr 14;4:612551 [PMID: 34337389]
  2. Risk Anal. 2022 Jul;42(7):1409-1422 [PMID: 35568963]
  3. J Behav Med. 2023 Apr;46(1-2):15-24 [PMID: 35032254]
  4. EClinicalMedicine. 2020 Sep;26:100495 [PMID: 32838242]
  5. Vaccine. 2015 Aug 14;33(34):4161-4 [PMID: 25896383]
  6. Z Psychol. 2015;223(4):205-214 [PMID: 27453805]
  7. Vaccine. 2022 Mar 18;40(13):2028-2035 [PMID: 35181151]
  8. Cancer Res. 2017 Apr 1;77(7):1575-1585 [PMID: 28087598]
  9. Occup Environ Med. 2003 Mar;60(3):227-34; quiz 164, 234 [PMID: 12598677]
  10. PLoS One. 2022 Nov 15;17(11):e0272627 [PMID: 36378633]
  11. Pers Individ Dif. 2021 Sep;179:110892 [PMID: 34866723]
  12. Front Public Health. 2021 Nov 11;9:745630 [PMID: 34858927]
  13. Found Comut Math. 2022 Aug 1;:1-35 [PMID: 35935470]
  14. PLoS One. 2021 Aug 23;16(8):e0256496 [PMID: 34424913]
  15. Brain Behav Immun. 2021 May;94:41-50 [PMID: 33713824]
  16. Vaccines (Basel). 2021 Dec 01;9(12): [PMID: 34960164]
  17. Soc Sci Med. 2021 Mar;272:113688 [PMID: 33485215]
  18. Vaccine. 2020 Sep 29;38(42):6500-6507 [PMID: 32863069]
  19. Vaccines (Basel). 2020 Oct 03;8(4): [PMID: 33022917]
  20. Epidemiology. 1999 Jan;10(1):37-48 [PMID: 9888278]
  21. N Engl J Med. 2021 Apr 22;384(16):1483-1487 [PMID: 33657291]
  22. Vaccines (Basel). 2021 Mar 22;9(3): [PMID: 33810131]
  23. Vaccine. 2022 Feb 16;40(8):1074-1081 [PMID: 35090777]
  24. Vaccine. 2021 Apr 15;39(16):2288-2294 [PMID: 33771392]
  25. Gates Open Res. 2019 Mar 18;3:886 [PMID: 31294419]
  26. Hum Vaccin Immunother. 2022 Nov 30;18(5):2055422 [PMID: 35536017]
  27. J Risk Uncertain. 2020;61(2):177-194 [PMID: 33223612]
  28. JMIR Infodemiology. 2021 Aug 12;1(1):e28800 [PMID: 34447924]
  29. Water Res. 2021 Apr 15;194:116952 [PMID: 33662684]
  30. J Healthc Manag. 2022 May 01;67(3):206-220 [PMID: 35576446]
  31. J Community Health. 2021 Apr;46(2):270-277 [PMID: 33389421]
  32. Mayo Clin Proc. 2021 Mar;96(3):699-707 [PMID: 33673921]
  33. Comput Biol Med. 1997 Jan;27(1):19-29 [PMID: 9055043]
  34. Annu Rev Public Health. 2001;22:189-212 [PMID: 11274518]
  35. Psychol Sci Public Interest. 2017 Dec;18(3):149-207 [PMID: 29611455]
  36. Vaccines (Basel). 2022 Aug 10;10(8): [PMID: 36016183]
  37. Hum Vaccin Immunother. 2022 Dec 31;18(1):1950504 [PMID: 34325612]
  38. PLoS One. 2021 Apr 16;16(4):e0250123 [PMID: 33861765]
  39. Acad Pediatr. 2021 May-Jun;21(4S):S9-S16 [PMID: 33958099]
  40. Artif Intell Med. 2016 Feb;67:75-93 [PMID: 26830286]
  41. BMC Public Health. 2021 Apr 28;21(1):818 [PMID: 33910558]
  42. Rand Health Q. 2022 Jun 30;9(3):12 [PMID: 35837516]
  43. Clin Transl Sci. 2022 Dec;15(12):2844-2857 [PMID: 36330587]
  44. PLoS One. 2022 May 3;17(5):e0268020 [PMID: 35503797]
  45. Nat Med. 2022 Feb;28(2):232-235 [PMID: 35022575]
  46. Front Genet. 2019 Jun 04;10:524 [PMID: 31214249]
  47. Econ Lett. 2021 Sep;206:109979 [PMID: 34230727]
  48. Health Psychol. 2016 Nov;35(11):1264-1275 [PMID: 27607136]
  49. Nat Hum Behav. 2022 Dec;6(12):1609-1610 [PMID: 36418535]
  50. Int J Health Policy Manag. 2021 Jun 26;: [PMID: 34273931]

MeSH Term

Humans
Bayes Theorem
COVID-19
COVID-19 Vaccines
Intention
Vaccination

Chemicals

COVID-19 Vaccines

Word Cloud

Created with Highcharts 10.0.0causalvaccineinterventionsCOVID-19interconnectednetworkhesitancypathwaysBayesianBNusingUSrevealedcomplexvariablesHolisticovercomerequiresystem-levelunderstandingcausesmechanismsgiveriseHoweverconventionalcorrelativeanalyseseasilyprovidenuancedinsightsusedunsupervisedhypothesis-freediscoveryalgorithmlearnintentiondatasurveyearly2021identifiedsocialresponsibilitysafetyanticipatedregretprimecandidatesmediateinfluencesSocialresponsibility'seffectgreatlyexceededimpactpoliticalaffiliationsweakcompareddirectfactorsapproachprovidesclearertargetsinterventionregressionsuggestingcaneffectivewayexploremultiplebehaviouralproblemsinformDiscoverydriversvaccinationintentions

Similar Articles

Cited By (1)