The domestication of animals has rendered horns less necessary for survival. Moreover, the use of polled and disbudded animals is interesting in order to avoid injuries of animals and handlers, among other advantages. We therefore conducted a comparative economic analysis of different traditional disbudding techniques versus selective breeding for polledness in Nelore cattle, the main beef breed of tropical systems in Brazil. The cost to obtain animals without horns was estimated in three different scenarios: disbudding with hot iron, disbudding with caustic paste, and phenotypic selection for polled animals. Price quotations of the materials were obtained in different states of the country and averaged. An initial frequency of horned animals of 92.16% was obtained based on the records of the Brazilian Association of Zebu Breeders. Selective breeding was found to be the best cost-effective scenario. This result differs from intensive production systems of dairy cattle in which traditional disbudding continues to be the best cost-effective scenario. The main explanation is the lack of difference in the price of Nelore semen from polled and horned bulls. Phenotypic selection for polled animals is the best cost-effective method, and it is in accordance with welfare practices. Care should be taken regarding the intensive use of few polled breeding animals in order to avoid inbreeding depression in other traits.
Associação Brasileira dos Criadores de Zebu (ABCZ). Raças Zebuínas: Nelore / Nelore Mocho. https://www.abcz.org.br/a-abcz/racaszebuinas/raca/8/nelore---nelore-mocho . Acessed 10 December 2021
Adcock, S.J.J., Tucker, C.B., 2020. Conditioned place preference reveals ongoing pain in calves 3 weeks after disbudding, Scientific Reports, 10, 1-9
[DOI: 10.1038/s41598-020-60260-7]
Alta Genetics (2021) Catálogo Corte zebu 2020/21. https://altagenetics.com.br/www.altagenetics.com.br/produtos/catalogos . Accessed 10 Dec 2021
Associação Nacional de Criadores e Pesquisadores (ANCP). Programa Nelore. https://www.ancp.org.br/programas/nelore/ . Acessed 10 December 2021
Bates, A.J., Eder P., Laven R.A., 2015. Effect of analgesia and anti-inflammatory treatment on weight gain and milk intake of dairy calves after disbudding, New Zealand Veterinary Journal, 63, 153-157
[DOI: 10.1080/00480169.2014.982739]
Bir, C., Widmar, N.O., Thompson, N.M., Townsend, J., Wolf, C.A., 2020. US respondents’ willingness to pay for Cheddar cheese from dairy cattle with different pasture access, antibiotic use, and dehorning practices, American Dairy Science, 103, 3234-3249
[DOI: 10.3168/jds.2019-17031]
Bučková, K., Moravcsíková, Á., Šárová, R., Rajmon, R., Špinka, M., 2022. Indication of social buffering in disbudded calves, Scientific Reports, 12, 1-8
[DOI: 10.1038/s41598-022-15919-8]
Bunter, K.L., Johnston, D.J., Wolcott, M.L., Fordyce, G., 2013. Factors associated with calf mortality in tropically adapted beef breeds managed in extensive Australian production systems, Animal Production Science, 54, 25-36
[DOI: 10.1071/AN12421]
Cole, J.B., 2015. A simple strategy for managing recessive disorders in a dairy cattle breeding program, Genetics Selection Evolution, 47, 1-13
[DOI: 10.1186/s12711-015-0174-9]
CRV Lagoa. Corte Zebu. https://www2.crvlagoa.com.br/cortezebunovo . Acessed 10 December 2021
Dotta, J.C., Falcão, A.J.S., Carneiro, P.L.S., Conti, A.C.M., Rezende, M.P.G., 2019. Estrutura populacional e depressão endogâmica em características de crescimento de bovinos da raça Nelore criados no bioma Amazônia, Livestock Research for Rural Development, 31, 1-12
GENEPLUS. Programa Geneplus Embrapa. https://geneplus.com.br/geneplus/programa-geneplus/ . Acessed 10 December 2021
Gingerich, K.N., Choulet, V., Miller-Cushon, E.K., 2020. Disbudding affects use of a shelter provided to group-housed dairy calves, Journal of Dairy Science, 103, 10519-10529
[DOI: 10.3168/jds.2020-18267]
Götz, K.U., Luntz, B., Robeis, J., Edel, C., Emmerling, R., Buitkamp, J., Anzenberger, H., Duda, J., 2015. Polled Fleckvieh (Simmental) cattle – Current state of the breeding program, Livestock Science, 179, 80-85
[DOI: 10.1016/j.livsci.2015.05.019]
Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística (IBGE), 2022. Variação acumulada no ano durante o Plano Real (%), dezembro 1995 - dezembro 2021. https://www.ibge.gov.br/estatisticas/economicas/precos-e-custos/9256-indice-nacional-de-precos-ao-consumidoramplo.html?edicao=20932&t=series-historicas . Acessed 10 December 2021
Kling-Eveillard, F., Knierim, U., Irrgang, N., Gottardo, F., Ricci, R., Dockes, A., 2015. Attitudes of farmers towards cattle dehorning, Livestock Science, 179, 12-21
[DOI: 10.1016/j.livsci.2015.05.012]
Knierim, U., Irrgang, N., Roth, B.A., 2015. To be or not to be - Consequences in cattle, Livestock Science, 179, 29-37
[DOI: 10.1016/j.livsci.2015.05.014]
Lima, F.S., De Vries, A., Risco, C.A., Santos, J.E.P., Thatcher, W.W.,2010. Economic comparison of natural service and timed artificial insemination breeding programs in dairy cattle, American Dairy Science, 93, 4404-4413
[DOI: 10.3168/jds.2009-2789]
Malhado, C.H.M., Carneiro, P.L.S., Pereira, D.G., Filho, R.M., 2008. Progresso genético e estrutura populacional do rebanho Nelore no Estado da Bahia, Pesquisa Agropecuária Brasileira, 43, 1163-1169
[DOI: 10.1590/S0100-204X2008000900010]
Medugorac, I., Seichter, D., Graf, A., Russ, I., Blum, H., Göpel, K.H., Rothammer, S., Förster, M., Krebs, S., 2012. Bovine Polledness – An Autosomal Dominant Trait with Allelic Heterogeneity, Plos One, 7(6): e39477
[DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0039477]
Mendonça, F.S., Vaz, R.Z., Leal, W.S., Restle, J., Pascoal, L.L., Vaz, M.B., Farias, G.D., 2016. Genetic group and horns presence in injuries and economic losses of bovine carcasses, Semina: Ciências Agrárias, 37, 4265-4273
Mueller, M.L., Cole, J.B., Sonstegard, T.S., Eenennaam, A.L., 2019. Comparison of gene editing versus conventional breeding to introgress the POLLED 29 allele into the US dairy cattle population, Journal of Dairy Science, 102, 4215-4226
[DOI: 10.3168/jds.2018-15892]
Mueller, M.L., Cole, J.B., Connors, N.K., Johnston, D.J., Randhawa, I.A.S., Eenennaam, A.L., 2021. Comparison of Gene Editing versus Conventional Breeding to Introgress the POLLED allele into the Tropically Adapted Australian Beef Cattle Population, Frontiers in Genetics, 12, 1-23
[DOI: 10.3389/fgene.2021.593154]
Nordquist, R.E., Staay, F.J.V.D., Van Eerdenburg, F.J.C.M., Velkers, F.C., Fijn, L., Arndt, S.S., 2017. Mutilating Procedures, Management Practices, and Housing Conditions That May Affect the Welfare of Farm Animals: Implications for Welfare Research, Animals, 7, 1-22
[DOI: 10.3390/ani7020012]
Programa de Melhoramento Genético de Zebuínos (PMGZ). Sistema Integrado de Avaliação Genética. 2021. https://www.abczstat.com.br/comunicacoes/sumario/default.aspx?acesso=publico . Acessed 10 December 2021
Randhawa, I.A.S., Burns, B.M., Mcgowan, M.R., Porto-Neto, L.R., Hayes, B.J., Ferretti, R., Schutt, K.M., Lyons, R.E., 2020. Optimized Genetic Testing for Polledness in Multiple Breeds of Cattle, G3, 10, 539-544
[DOI: 10.1534/g3.119.400866]
Randhawa, I.A.S., Mcgowan, M.R., Porto-Neto, L.R., Hayes, B.J., Lyons, R.E., 2021. Comparison of Genetic Merit for Weight and Meat Traits between the Polled and Horned Cattle in Multiple Beef Breeds, Animals, 11, 1-18
[DOI: 10.3390/ani11030870]
Rezende, M.P.G., Conde, E.A.S.L., Borges, A.C., Carneiro, P.L.S., Filho, R.M., Malhado, C.H.M., 2017. Estrutura populacional do rebanho Nelore criado no semiárido do nordeste brasileiro, Ciência Animal brasileira, 18, 1-14
[DOI: 10.1590/1089-6891v18e-38048]
Sales, M.F.L., Rosa, B.L., Palu, A.B., Maia, G.F.N., Miranda, L.A., Peixoto, R.M., Diniz, J.V.A., 2021. Productive performance and economic viability of beef cattle subjected to different castration methods in the Western Amazon, Livestock Science, 251, 1-7
[DOI: 10.1016/j.livsci.2021.104633]
Schafberg, R., Swawe, H.H., 2015. The history of breeding for polled cattle, Livestock Science, 179, 54-70
[DOI: 10.1016/j.livsci.2015.05.017]
Stafuzza, N.B., Silva, R.M.O., Peripolli, E., Bezerra, L.A.F., Lôbo, R.B., Magnabosco, C.U., Croce, F.A., Osterstock, J.B., Munari, D.P., Lourenco, D.A.L., Baldi, F., 2018. Genome-wide association study provides insights into genes related with horn development in Nelore beef cattle, Plos One, 13(8): e0202978
[DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0202978]
Thompson, N.M., Widmar, N.O., Schutz, M.M., Cole, J.B., Wolf, C.A., 2017. Economic considerations of breeding for polled dairy cows versus dehorning in the United States, American Dairy Science, 100, 4941-4952
[DOI: 10.3168/jds.2016-12099]
Utsunomiya, Y.T., Torrecilha, R.B.P., Milanesi, M., Paulan, S.C., Utsunomiya, A.T.H., Garcia, J.F., 2019. Hornless Nellore cattle (Bos indicus) carrying a novel 110 kbp duplication variant of the polled locus, Animal Genetics, 50, 187-188
[DOI: 10.1111/age.12764]
Weidemar, N., Tetens, J., Jagannathan, V., Menoud, A., Neuenhwander, S., Bruggmann, R., Thaller, G., Drögemuller, C., 2014. Independent polled mutations leading to complex gene expression differences in cattle, PLoS ONE, 9: e93435
[DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0093435]
Widmar, N. J. O., M. M. Schutz, and J. B. Cole. 2013. Breeding for polled dairy cows versus dehorning: Preliminary cost assessments and discussion. J. Dairy Sci. 96(E. Suppl. 1):602 (Abstr. TH373).