Exploring Compassion towards Laboratory Animals in UK- and China-Based Undergraduate Biomedical Sciences Students.

Richard Fitzpatrick, Nicola Romanò, John Menzies
Author Information
  1. Richard Fitzpatrick: School of Biological Sciences, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh EH9 3FD, UK. ORCID
  2. Nicola Romanò: Centre for Discovery Brain Sciences, Edinburgh Medical School: Biomedical Sciences, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh EH8 9XD, UK. ORCID
  3. John Menzies: Centre for Discovery Brain Sciences, Edinburgh Medical School: Biomedical Sciences, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh EH8 9XD, UK.

Abstract

Taking a compassionate approach to the non-human animals used in biomedical research is in line with emerging ideas around a "culture of care". It is important to expose biomedical sciences students to the concept of a culture of care at an early stage and give them opportunities to explore related practices and ideas. However, there is no simple tool to explore biomedical sciences students' attitudes towards laboratory animals. Accordingly, there is little understanding of students' feelings towards these animals, or a means of quantifying potential changes to these feelings. We developed a 12-item questionnaire designed to explore compassion (the Laboratory Animal Compassion Scale; LACS) and used it with UK-based and China-based samples of undergraduate biomedical sciences students. In the same samples, we also explored a harm-benefit analysis task and students' beliefs regarding some mental characteristics of laboratory animals, then drew correlations with the quantitative measure of compassion. Compassion levels were stable across years of study and were not related to students' level of experience of working with laboratory animals. We observed a higher level of compassion in females versus males overall, and a higher level overall in the UK-based versus China-based sample. In a task pitting animal suffering against human wellbeing, students' compassion levels correlated negatively with their acceptance of animal suffering. Compassion levels correlated positively with a belief in animals being conscious and possessing emotions. These data are in line with studies that show compassion is gender- and nationality/culture-dependent, and points to links between compassion, beliefs, and choices.

Keywords

References

  1. Best Pract Res Clin Rheumatol. 2008 Mar;22(1):191-205 [PMID: 18328989]
  2. Sci Rep. 2019 Dec 20;9(1):19555 [PMID: 31862944]
  3. Science. 2023 Mar 10;379(6636):974-977 [PMID: 36893223]
  4. Cureus. 2021 Dec 6;13(12):e20205 [PMID: 35004025]
  5. Public Underst Sci. 2013 Aug;22(6):691-703 [PMID: 23885052]
  6. PLoS One. 2020 Jan 21;15(1):e0227948 [PMID: 31961885]
  7. J Neurosci Methods. 2018 Apr 15;300:20-25 [PMID: 28502554]
  8. Animals (Basel). 2022 Feb 09;12(4): [PMID: 35203123]
  9. Animals (Basel). 2019 Oct 11;9(10): [PMID: 31614498]
  10. Philosophy. 1996 Jan;71(275):41-61 [PMID: 11660432]
  11. Nature. 2011 Feb 24;470(7335):452-3 [PMID: 21350461]
  12. Vet Rec. 2000 Mar 4;146(10):269-72 [PMID: 10749039]
  13. BMC Biol. 2022 Jan 13;20(1):15 [PMID: 35022024]
  14. J Pers Soc Psychol. 2019 Jun;116(6):1011-1029 [PMID: 29517258]
  15. J Vet Med Educ. 2017 Summer;44(2):217-222 [PMID: 28346050]
  16. Animals (Basel). 2021 Sep 08;11(9): [PMID: 34573605]
  17. Integr Comp Biol. 2018 Dec 1;58(6):1235-1246 [PMID: 30052942]
  18. Front Med (Lausanne). 2021 Nov 08;8:758377 [PMID: 34820397]
  19. Altern Lab Anim. 2008 Jul;36(3):327-42 [PMID: 18662096]
  20. Animals (Basel). 2022 Jan 10;12(2): [PMID: 35049779]
  21. ILAR J. 2021 Sep 24;60(3):373-388 [PMID: 32311030]
  22. Vet Rec. 2017 Apr 15;180(15):378 [PMID: 28213530]
  23. ILAR J. 2021 Sep 24;60(3):415-423 [PMID: 32717051]
  24. Sci Rep. 2020 Sep 3;10(1):14562 [PMID: 32884048]
  25. J Vet Med Educ. 2017 Spring;44(1):179-186 [PMID: 28206834]
  26. Biol Philos. 2023;38(4):25 [PMID: 37388763]
  27. J Am Assoc Lab Anim Sci. 2022 Nov 1;61(6):634-643 [PMID: 36253073]
  28. Clin Psychol Rev. 2016 Jul;47:15-27 [PMID: 27267346]
  29. ILAR J. 2021 Sep 24;60(3):347-365 [PMID: 31608362]
  30. Lab Anim. 2019 Nov 19;:23677219887998 [PMID: 31744380]

Word Cloud

Created with Highcharts 10.0.0animalscompassionbiomedicalstudents'scienceslaboratoryCompassionstudentsexploretowardslevelslevelusedlineideasculturecarerelatedfeelingsLaboratoryUK-basedChina-basedsamplestaskbeliefshigherversusoverallanimalsufferingcorrelatedTakingcompassionateapproachnon-humanresearchemergingaround"culturecare"importantexposeconceptearlystagegiveopportunitiespracticesHoweversimpletoolattitudesAccordinglylittleunderstandingmeansquantifyingpotentialchangesdeveloped12-itemquestionnairedesignedAnimalScaleLACSundergraduatealsoexploredharm-benefitanalysisregardingmentalcharacteristicsdrewcorrelationsquantitativemeasurestableacrossyearsstudyexperienceworkingobservedfemalesmalessamplepittinghumanwellbeingnegativelyacceptancepositivelybeliefconsciouspossessingemotionsdatastudiesshowgender-nationality/culture-dependentpointslinkschoicesExploringAnimalsUK-China-BasedUndergraduateBiomedicalSciencesStudents

Similar Articles

Cited By

No available data.