Animal research, ethical boundary-work, and the geographies of veterinary expertise.

Alistair Anderson, Pru Hobson-West
Author Information
  1. Alistair Anderson: School of Sociology and Social Policy University of Nottingham Nottingham UK. ORCID
  2. Pru Hobson-West: School of Sociology and Social Policy University of Nottingham Nottingham UK. ORCID

Abstract

The veterinary profession has been relatively understudied in social science, though recent work has highlighted the geographic dimensions of veterinary expertise. This paper draws on in-depth qualitative interviews with Named Veterinary Surgeons (NVSs) working in UK animal research to demonstrate how and why they distinguish between ethical aspects of veterinary work in the spaces of the laboratory and general clinical practice. The paper mobilises the sociological concept of ethical boundary-work to help understand how animal research - often assumed to represent a contentious ethical space - is constructed positively as a space for veterinary work. Findings suggest first, that NVSs differentiate between laboratory veterinary-work and clinical work based on the scale at which veterinary expertise functions in the provision of healthcare to animals. Second, NVSs highlight a geography of veterinary authority in which veterinary expertise is felt to be more successfully applied in the laboratory compared with the clinic, where professional expertise competes with other sources of information and clients' finances and behaviours. Third, NVSs articulate a geography of consistency in which veterinary care in the laboratory is claimed to be more consistent between animals, as opposed to in the clinic, where animal experience may be influenced by individual owner characteristics. Overall, we show how through engaging in this kind of ethical boundary-work NVSs are not only presenting a form of scientific practice as 'ethical', they are also constructing a professional topology of veterinary practice and expertise. Finally, the paper argues for greater attentiveness to veterinary geographies beyond the more routine spaces of veterinary practice.

Keywords

References

  1. Sci Technol Human Values. 2018 Jul;43(4):622-648 [PMID: 30008492]
  2. Sci Technol Human Values. 2018 Jul;43(4):694-722 [PMID: 30008494]
  3. Animals (Basel). 2013 Mar 19;3(1):238-73 [PMID: 26487317]
  4. Sci Technol Human Values. 1994 Spring;19(2):189-204 [PMID: 11652277]
  5. Sociol Health Illn. 2011 May;33(4):570-85 [PMID: 21226735]
  6. Nature. 2006 Dec 14;444(7121):811 [PMID: 17167451]
  7. Med Humanit. 2020 Dec;46(4):499-511 [PMID: 32075866]
  8. Sociology. 2012 Aug;46(4):649-663 [PMID: 27708461]
  9. Vet Rec. 2018 Jun 9;182(23):664 [PMID: 29602799]
  10. Lab Anim. 2015 Apr;49(2):89-99 [PMID: 25416607]
  11. Front Vet Sci. 2020 Oct 15;7:569545 [PMID: 33195550]
  12. Trans Inst Br Geogr. 2023 Sep;48(3):491-505 [PMID: 38505469]
  13. Stud Hist Philos Sci. 2021 Oct;89:177-187 [PMID: 34455260]
  14. Sci Technol Human Values. 2018 Jul;43(4):671-693 [PMID: 30008493]
  15. J Med Ethics. 2010 Jan;36(1):46-9 [PMID: 20026693]
  16. Vet Rec. 2022 Jan;190(1):e773 [PMID: 34382692]
  17. Sociol Health Illn. 2006 Sep;28(6):732-48 [PMID: 17184415]
  18. Animals (Basel). 2020 Oct 13;10(10): [PMID: 33066272]
  19. J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2011 May 15;238(10):1275-82 [PMID: 21568772]
  20. Sociol Health Illn. 2020 Feb;42(2):393-406 [PMID: 31657051]

Grants

  1. /Wellcome Trust
  2. 205393/Z/16/Z/Wellcome Trust

Word Cloud

Created with Highcharts 10.0.0veterinaryexpertiseNVSsethicallaboratoryworkpracticepaperanimalresearchboundary-workanimalsinterviewsspacesclinical-spacegeographyclinicprofessionalcaregeographiesprofessionrelativelyunderstudiedsocialsciencethoughrecenthighlightedgeographicdimensionsdrawsin-depthqualitativeNamedVeterinarySurgeonsworkingUKdemonstratedistinguishaspectsgeneralmobilisessociologicalconcepthelpunderstandoftenassumedrepresentcontentiousconstructedpositivelyFindingssuggestfirstdifferentiateveterinary-workbasedscalefunctionsprovisionhealthcareSecondhighlightauthorityfeltsuccessfullyappliedcomparedcompetessourcesinformationclients'financesbehavioursThirdarticulateconsistencyclaimedconsistentopposedexperiencemayinfluencedindividualownercharacteristicsOverallshowengagingkindpresentingformscientific'ethical'alsoconstructingtopologyFinallyarguesgreaterattentivenessbeyondroutineAnimalUnitedKingdomethics

Similar Articles

Cited By