Virtual On-Call: Use of Low-Fidelity Simulation to Improve Preparedness for Practice.

Molly M Nichols, Amy Radcliffe, Allen Daniel
Author Information
  1. Molly M Nichols: Medical Education and Simulation, Maidstone and Tunbridge Wells National Health Service (NHS) Trust, Kent, GBR.
  2. Amy Radcliffe: Medical Education and Simulation, Maidstone and Tunbridge Wells National Health Service (NHS) Trust, Kent, GBR.
  3. Allen Daniel: Medical Education and Simulation, Maidstone and Tunbridge Wells National Health Service (NHS) Trust, Kent, GBR.

Abstract

Background Many newly qualified doctors feel unprepared for clinical practice. The literature identifies themes including difficulties with clinical reasoning, emergency management, handover, and prioritization of tasks. Although there is an expected level of anxiety for newly qualified doctors, this appears to be amplified with respect to the first on-call shifts that encompass these themes. Materials and methods Virtual on-call (VOC) is a low-fidelity, ward-based simulation for senior undergraduate medical students designed to simulate an on-call in a supported environment with high psychological fidelity. Sessions were provided across two hospital sites for students to attend voluntarily. Three simulation sessions were created, each composed of five medical and surgical scenarios of differing complexity. Students responded to simulated bleeps (pager messages) and attended relevant wards to find patient notes and complete paper-based tasks. A student-led handover concluded the simulation followed by facilitator-led structured feedback and debrief. Students completed pre- and post-session questionnaires collecting quantitative and qualitative feedback. Facilitators received feedback on their teaching. A total of 30 resident doctors volunteered to teach, and 39 students attended at least one session. Results Pre-session questionnaires highlighted that 91% of respondents (n=32) felt scared/nervous/petrified about the idea of their first on-call. Prior to the first VOC session, the baseline assessment highlighted a lack of confidence among medical students regarding on-call working. Post-session results (session one) showed statistically significant increases in confidence in all the themes assessed (paired t-test with statistical significance considered at p<0.05). Forty-seven percent of first-session participants (n=14) felt positive about on-call working after attending VOC. Students who completed multiple sessions continued to have significant increases in their overall confidence levels between sessions. All students who attended three sessions were left feeling positive about their first on-call (n=2). About 95% (n=38) reported a constructive learning environment which was useful to improve preparedness for practice and time management skills. Although students reported finding the experience stressful at times, they remarked how it was beneficial to have "the opportunity to practice a wide range of skills while in an on-call simulation, how to manage acute situations, how to prioritize, and how to escalate to a senior." They reported feeling "more confident holding the bleep, finding guidance, and seeking guidance." Conclusion This program fills an unmet educational need. Feedback was overwhelmingly positive, displaying significantly increased confidence in multiple skills associated with being a safe and successful on-call doctor. We hope that the confidence gained from the on-call program will translate to improved practice when the participants qualify as doctors with a positive impact on patient care.

Keywords

References

  1. J Eur CME. 2020 Oct 25;9(1):1832749 [PMID: 33224625]
  2. AEM Educ Train. 2020 Apr 25;4(3):284-290 [PMID: 32704600]
  3. Med Teach. 2012;34(2):123-35 [PMID: 22288990]
  4. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2020 Mar;88(3):440-445 [PMID: 32107357]
  5. BMJ Open. 2017 Jan 13;7(1):e013656 [PMID: 28087554]
  6. Psychol Rep. 1998 Apr;82(2):627-42 [PMID: 9621740]
  7. BMC Med Educ. 2019 Jan 21;19(1):29 [PMID: 30665397]
  8. BMC Med Educ. 2021 Mar 17;21(1):165 [PMID: 33731104]
  9. JAMA. 2013 Nov 27;310(20):2191-4 [PMID: 24141714]
  10. Fam Med. 2023 Nov;55(10):667-676 [PMID: 37643091]
  11. Postgrad Med J. 2014 Feb;90(1060):63-8 [PMID: 23223778]
  12. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2014 Jun 10;111(23):8410-5 [PMID: 24821756]

Word Cloud

Created with Highcharts 10.0.0on-callconfidencemedicalstudentspracticesimulationsessionspositivedoctorsfirstVOCattendedfeedbacksessionreportedpreparednessskillsnewlyqualifiedclinicalmanagementhandovertasksAlthoughthemesVirtualseniorundergraduateenvironmentfidelityStudentspatientquestionnairesonehighlightedfeltworkingsignificantparticipantsfeelingfinding"bleepguidancedoctorBackgroundManyfeelunpreparedliteratureidentifiesthemes includingdifficultiesreasoning emergencyprioritizationexpectedlevelanxietyappearsamplifiedrespectshiftsencompassMaterialsmethodslow-fidelityward-basedstudents designedsimulatesupportedhighpsychologicalSessionsprovided acrosstwohospitalsites forattendvoluntarilyThreecreatedcomposedfivesurgicalscenariosdifferingcomplexityrespondedsimulatedbleepspagermessagesrelevantwardsfindnotesand completepaper-basedstudent-ledhandover concludedsimulation followedby facilitator-ledstructureddebriefcompletedpre-post-sessioncollectingquantitativequalitativeFacilitatorsreceivedteachingtotal30residentvolunteeredteach39leastResultsPre-session91%respondentsn=32scared/nervous/petrifiedideaPriorbaselineassessmentlackamongregardingPost-sessionresultsshowedstatisticallyincreasesassessedpairedt-teststatisticalsignificanceconsideredat p<005Forty-sevenpercent offirst-sessionn=14attending Studentscompleted multiplecontinuedincreases inoveralllevelsthreelefttheir firstn=295% n=38constructivelearningusefulimprovetimeexperiencestressfultimesremarkedbeneficial"theopportunitywiderangemanageacutesituationsprioritizeescalate"moreconfidentholdingseekingConclusionThis program fillsan unmeteducationalneed Feedbackoverwhelminglydisplaying significantlyincreasedmultipleassociatedsafesuccessfulhopegainedprogram willtranslateimprovedqualifydoctors with aimpactcareOn-Call:UseLow-FidelitySimulationImprovePreparednessPracticejuniorlowshifttrainingresidencyeducationsurgical-educationstudent

Similar Articles

Cited By