Prevention and control of ship-source pollution in the Arctic shipping routes: challenges and countermeasures.

Cheng Zhang, Jia-Qi Yang
Author Information
  1. Cheng Zhang: China Institute of Boundary and Ocean Studies, Wuhan University, Wuhan, 430072, China. ncdxzc@163.com. ORCID
  2. Jia-Qi Yang: China Institute of Boundary and Ocean Studies, Wuhan University, Wuhan, 430072, China.

Abstract

Ship-source pollution is one of the important contributors to marine environment pollution. Because the legal status of the Arctic shipping routes is not clear, there is a considerable degree of dispute in the application of the rules on the prevention and control of ship-source pollution. The increased melting of sea ice undermines the legal legitimacy of the "ice-covered areas" clause under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea. The conflict between the application of the Polar Code and "ice-covered areas" will also reach an initial conclusion in the context of melting sea ice. However, the inadequacy of ship-source pollution rules in the Polar Code hampers its application, which has led to a negative impact on the more active role in the governance of pollution from Arctic shipping. For replying to the Challenges in the prevention of ship-source pollution in Arctic shipping routes, the relevant rules of the Polar Code need to be further improved, while a more binding HFO ban according to ship types needs to be applied. Therefore, a more important role in the future Arctic governance mechanism will be played by the enhanced enforcement of the Polar Code, meanwhile, the target for uniform international regulation of preventing and controlling ship-source pollution in Arctic shipping routes should be achieved.

Keywords

References

  1. Abbasov F, Gilliam L (2018) Cost analysis of Arctic HFO ban for cruise shipping: a case study of the MS Rotterdam operations in the Arctic summer 2018. European Federation for Transport and Environment. https://safety4sea.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/TE-Cost-analysis-of-Arctic-HFO-ban-for-Cruise-shipping-2018_10.pdf . Accessed 30 March 2023
  2. Allen CH (2014) International law for seating offices, 6th edn. Naval Institute Press
  3. Arctic Council (2009). Arctic marine shipping assessment 2009 Report. Website Available at https://oaarchive.arctic-council.org/bitstreams/cbb4cce2-3fbf-46f4-aede-2e3e01cd5e89/download (arcticcouncil.org)
  4. Arctic Council (2020) Arctic shipping report #1: the increase in Arctic shipping 2013 -2019. https://www.pame.is/document-library/shipping-documents/arctic-ship-traffic-data-documents/reports/arctic-shipping-status-reports-jpg-version/arctic-shipping-report-1-the-increase-in-arctic-shipping-2013-2019-jpgs . Accessed March 14, 2023
  5. Arctic Council (2020) Heavy fuel oil use by ships in the Arctic 2019. https://pame.is/document-library/pame-reports-new/pame-ministerial-deliverables/2021-12th-arctic-council-ministerial-meeting-reykjavik-iceland/794-assr-2-heavy-fuel-oil-hfo-use-by-ships-in-the-arctic-2019/file . Accessed 30 March 2023
  6. Bai J (2021) The trend of Arctic shipping heavy oil management and control in the perspective of sustainable development and China’s response. Dongyue Tribune 10:13
  7. Bai JY, Chircop A (2020) The regulation of heavy fuel oil in arctic shipping: interests, measures, and impacts. governance of arctic shipping. In: Chircop A, Goerlandt F, Aporta C, Pelot R et al (Eds)Governance of Arctic Shipping Rethinking Risk, Human Impacts and Regulation (pp 265–284) Springer
  8. Bartenstein K, Dremliuga R, Prisekina N (2022) Regulation of Arctic shipping in Canada and Russia. Arctic Rev Law Polit 13:338–360
  9. Bond TC et al (2013) Bounding the role of black carbon in the climate system: a scientific assessment. J Geophys Res: Atmos 118(11);5380–5552. https://doi.org/10.1002/jgrd.50171
  10. Comer B, Olmer N, Mao X, Roy B, Rutherford D (2017) Prevalence of heavy fuel oil and black carbon in Arctic shipping, 2015 to 2025
  11. Comer B, Olmer N, Mao XL, Roy B, Rutherford D (2017) Black carbon emissionsand fuel use in global shipping, 2015. The International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT), Washington, DC
  12. Comer B, Osipova L, Georgeff E, Mao X (2020) The international maritime organization’s proposed arctic heavy fuel oil ban: likely impacts and opportunities for improvement. The International Council on Clean Transportation, Washington, DC
  13. Corbett JJ, Lack DA, Winebrake JJ, Harder S, Silberman JA, Gold M (2010) Arctic shipping emissions inventories and future scenarios. Atmos Chem Phys 10(19):9689–9704 [DOI: 10.5194/acp-10-9689-2010]
  14. Dalaklis D, Drewniak M, Christodoulou A, Sheehan R, Dalaklis A, Andreadakis A (2023) Future Arctic regulatory interventions: discussing the impact of banning the use of heavy fuel oil. Polar Geogr 46(2–3):75–94 [DOI: 10.1080/1088937X.2023.2238794]
  15. GESAMP (1990) The state of the marine environment. Blackwell Scientific Publications
  16. Ghosh S, Rubly C (2015) The emergence of Arctic shipping: issues, threats, costs, and risk-mitigating strategies of the Polar Code. Aust J Marit Ocean Aff 7(3):171–182 [DOI: 10.1080/18366503.2015.1093695]
  17. Guo P (2009) Research on the international issues of the Arctic sea route. Ocean Press, pp 5–9
  18. Hong N (2020) China’s role in the Arctic: observing and being observed. Routledge [DOI: 10.4324/9780429328138]
  19. IMO (2020a) Sub-committee on Pollution Prevention and Response (PPR 7). https://www.imo.org/en/MediaCentre/MeetingSummaries/Pages/PPR-7th-Session.aspx . Accessed March 11, 2023
  20. IMO (2020b) Initial results of a black carbon measurement campaign with emphasis on the impact of the fuel oil quality on black carbon emissions. https://www.euractiv.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2020/01/PPR-7-8-Initial-results-of-a-Black-Carbon-measurement-campaign-with-emphasis-on-the-impact-of-the-Finland-and-Germany.pdf . Accessed at March 24, 2023
  21. Kong Q, Jiang C, Ng AK (2021) The economic impacts of restricting black carbon emissions on cargo shipping in the Polar Code area. Transp Res Part a: Policy Pract 147:159–176
  22. Kristin B (2019) Between the Polar Code and Article 234: the balance in Canada’s Arctic shipping safety and pollution prevention regulations. Ocean Development & International Law 50(4):337
  23. Li Z, Deng Z (2021) Application prospects of Arctic routes and its impact on world economy and geopolitics. Eurasian Econ 251(2):98
  24. Thorén AM (2014) Article 234 UNCLOS and the polar code: the interaction between regulations on different levels in the Arctic region (Master's thesis, University of Olso, Faculty of Law)
  25. Thorsell DE, Leschine TM (2016) An evaluation of oil pollution prevention strategies in the Arctic: a comparison of Canadian and US approaches. Mar Policy 72:255–262 [DOI: 10.1016/j.marpol.2016.04.042]
  26. US Environmental Protection Agency (2012) Report to congress on black carbon. Chapter 2. Black Carbon and Its Effects on Climate, pp 17–66
  27. Xu G (2017) An analysis of the history of the development of the Northern Sea Route in Russia before the October Revolution. Russia Studies 207(5):61
  28. Yuan X (2019) International governance of Arctic maritime black carbon emissions: current situation, challenges and institutional construction. Pac J 27(7):41–54

Grants

  1. 600460012/Wuhan University Humanities and Social Sciences Research Project in 2023

MeSH Term

Ships
Arctic Regions
Environmental Pollution
Environmental Monitoring
Ice Cover

Word Cloud

Created with Highcharts 10.0.0pollutionArcticshippingship-sourceroutesPolarCodeapplicationrulesShip-sourceimportantlegalpreventioncontrolmeltingseaice"ice-coveredareas"willrolegovernanceonecontributorsmarineenvironmentstatusclearconsiderabledegreedisputeincreasedundermineslegitimacyclauseUnitedNationsConventionLawSeaconflictalsoreachinitialconclusioncontextHoweverinadequacyhamperslednegativeimpactactivereplyingChallengesrelevantneedimprovedbindingHFObanaccordingshiptypesneedsappliedThereforefuturemechanismplayedenhancedenforcementmeanwhiletargetuniforminternationalregulationpreventingcontrollingachievedPreventionroutes:challengescountermeasuresEnvironmentprotection

Similar Articles

Cited By

No available data.