The purpose of this study was to validate the success of revision arthroscopic circumferential allograft labral reconstruction (CLR) in nonarthritic hips, which, in the rare case of failure, had previously undergone labral reconstruction by the same surgeon. Using a minimum of 24-month follow-up, data from 24 hips having undergone revision CLR were analyzed to determine improvements in patient-reported outcomes (PROs). All included cases completed a minimum of 24 months follow-up, with a success rate of 96%. All PROs improved significantly, with exceptionally strong measures of effect. Modified Harris Hip Scores improved by a mean of 26.68 points, with 88% of patients meeting the minimal clinically important difference (MCID) (+6.49, ≤ .001, = 1.32). Lower Extremity Functional Scale scores improved by a mean of 21.88 points, with 78% of patients meeting the MCID (+7.79, ≤ .001, = 1.32). pain as rated by the Visual Analog Scale, including at rest, during activities of daily living, and with sports, was significantly improved with strong measures of effect, with >75% of patients having met the MCID. This study validated that a failed labral reconstruction of the hip can be revised safely and effectively to another labral reconstruction of the hip. While labral reconstruction has broadly been shown to result in highly favorable outcomes, this study demonstrated that in the rare case of failure, revision CLR is not only feasible but results in improved pain and functionality.
